IPO ETFs

As the financial markets continue to innovate, investors seek novel ways to diversify and capitalise on emerging opportunities. One such innovation is the IPO Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF), designed to offer exposure to the most promising newly public companies.

‍

What Are IPO ETFs?

IPO ETFs are specialised funds that track a basket of companies that have recently gone public. The primary objective of these ETFs is to capture the performance of initial public offerings (IPOs) during their early stages, which can often be the most volatile yet potentially rewarding period. These ETFs typically include companies for a certain period post-IPO, ranging from several months to a few years, depending on the specific criteria set by the fund.

For instance, the Renaissance IPO ETF (ticker: IPO) follows the Renaissance IPO Index, which aims to represent 80% of the market capitalisation of newly public companies that meet specific size, liquidity and free float criteria. Another example is the First Trust US Equity Opportunities ETF (ticker: FPX), which tracks the IPOX-100 U.S. Index, capturing the performance of the top 100 U.S. IPOs over their first 1,000 trading days.

‍

Market Trends in IPO ETFs

The IPO market has seen significant fluctuations in recent years, affecting the performance and attractiveness of IPO ETFs. In 2023, the IPO market was relatively muted, but signs of revival appeared in early 2024. The Renaissance IPO ETF, for example, posted a remarkable 55% gain in 2023 despite broader market challenges. This surge can be attributed to a few high-performing tech IPOs and a general market uptrend.

Market observers have noted that IPO activity tends to be cyclical, with periods of high activity followed by lulls. In the first four months of 2024, there were 370 IPOs globally, raising approximately $32.3 billion, reflecting a significant uptick compared to the previous year. Noteworthy debuts included the European private equity firm CVC and U.S.-based Astera Labs, which saw their stocks rise by 25% and 72%, respectively, on the first day of trading.

‍

A Critical Analysis of IPO ETFs

While IPO ETFs offer a unique investment opportunity, they come with inherent risks and challenges. One major concern is the high volatility associated with newly public companies. IPOs often experience significant price swings, driven by market speculation and the initial excitement surrounding new listings. For instance, while some IPOs like Astera Labs have seen substantial first-day gains, others, such as the German retailer Douglas, have flopped, demonstrating the unpredictable nature of IPO performance.

Moreover, the performance of IPO ETFs can be inconsistent over different time horizons. Although these funds might show strong performance over one and five-year periods, they have been known to underperform over a three-year span compared to broader market indices like the S&P 500 or Euro Stoxx 50. This variability underscores the importance of timing and market conditions in determining the success of IPO investments.

Additionally, the fees associated with IPO ETFs can be relatively high. For example, the Renaissance IPO ETF charges 60 basis points, while the First Trust US Equity Opportunities ETF charges 61 basis points. These costs can erode overall returns, especially during periods of market underperformance.

‍

The Future for IPO ETFs

IPO ETFs represent an intriguing avenue for investors looking to tap into the potential of newly public companies. They offer diversified exposure to a high-growth segment of the market that can deliver substantial returns during bullish phases. However, the inherent volatility and associated risks require a cautious approach. Investors should be mindful of market cycles, the specific composition of the ETF and the associated fees when considering IPO ETFs as part of their investment strategy.

As the market dynamics continue to evolve, IPO ETFs will remain a focal point for investors seeking to balance the allure of high returns with the need for prudent risk management.